How to Handle Fake Google Reviews Without Losing Your Mind

by | Mar 27, 2025

Handling Fake Google Reviews

Fake Google reviews can feel like a gut punch, especially when you’ve put your heart and soul into building a stellar reputation. While it’s tempting to fight fire with fire, there’s a smarter, calmer way to tackle fake reviews in Australia that protects your brand and maintains your sanity.

Having said that, you will want to act quickly to limit the damage done to both your brand, as well as your SEO efforts. Yes, a negative review may negatively impact your overall Google ranking.

1. Damage Control First

Respond quickly and professionally to the questionable review. Calmly and politely highlight your commitment to delivering exceptional customer service. A professional response reassures potential customers and demonstrates transparency.

Example:
“We value customer feedback and always strive to provide outstanding service. However, we haven’t been able to locate your details in our records. Please contact us directly so we can assist you promptly.”

2. Flag it with Google

If the review breaches Google’s guidelines (fake names, defamatory statements, or harassment), you can flag it for removal. Google typically reviews these flags promptly.

Quick Steps to Flag a Review:

  • Sign in to your Google Business Profile.

  • Navigate to “Reviews.”

  • Locate the fake review, click the three-dot menu, and choose “Report review.”

3. Legal Action? Tread Carefully

Legal routes such as defamation claims are tricky in Australia and often expensive. Always consult a legal professional to understand your options clearly before proceeding with letters or actions. You can also check out review removal services which may or may not be successful, but these typically charge per successful removal anyway.

4. Encourage Genuine Positive Reviews

The best defence is a good offence. Encourage satisfied customers to leave honest, positive reviews, effectively balancing out any potential damage from fakes.

Pro tip: Provide customers with a simple link to your review page, making it quick and hassle-free for them to share their experience. Check out our other blog posts on how to generate more 5-star Google reviews.

Fake reviews are undeniably frustrating, but handling them smartly ensures your business reputation remains strong. Keep calm, stay professional, and let your genuine Aussie customers do the talking!

Want to receive updates of our digital marketing insights?

Get notified whenever we publish a new blog post & get access to exclusive content by subscribing to our email newsletter.

We strictly respect your privacy. We will NEVER spam you and your details will never be sold to third-parties. That’s just not cool!

About the author

Oliver Leeb is the founder and Managing Director of 3am Ideas. He holds a Master of Marketing from Curtin University in Perth, and since founding the agency in 2014 he has helped small and medium businesses across Australia turn their marketing into measurable, trackable results. He is also the founder of Facilit8.

Oliver is relentlessly data-driven, and a little evangelical about it. His mission is to show business owners the power already sitting in their own data, and how to use it to make smarter, calmer marketing decisions, without the hype that clutters so much of the industry.

3am Ideas is a Perth-based digital marketing agency that has looked after businesses right across the country since 2014. We work as your Virtual Marketing Officer: part of your team, invested in your results, and in it with you for the long haul.

We're here for you. Let's get the job done.

3am-Ideas-Perth-Small-Business-Digital-Marketing-Agency-SEO-Social-Web-Wordpress-2022